The prosecutor had previously sent him an avalanche of unwanted gifts, prosecutors revealed in court on Friday – while a judge complained of a ruling on the suspect.
Michelle Mootreddy sat behind a screen of white metal bars while being executed on burglary, trespassing, stalking and harassment during the virtual trial in Richmond County Criminal Court – before she was released during supervised release.
“In this case, the defendant acted involving numerous incidents, including sending letters and parcels to Peter Davidson’s home, and then entering the home without permission,” Assistant District Attorney Matthew Stupp said.
Judge Ronald Castorina Jr. released Mootreddy after release under supervision – while issuing a restraining order in favor of Davidson, his younger sister Casey Davidson and his mother Amy Waters.
“The court gives a full order of protection,” the judge told Mootreddy. “Do you understand that?”
“Yes,” she replied in a butterfly voice.
Mootreddy, who once issued a press release claiming she and the comedian were arrested, arrived at his home around 3pm on Thursday when he was not home.
She knocks on the door, and a woman who answers it tells the star-stricken fan to leave – but Mootreddy crawls to the side of the house, sneaks in through a side door and enters the kitchen, according to a criminal complaint.
The woman who answered the door, Marjorie Agostino, again told Mootreddy to shout, authorities said.
‘I’m here for Pete. “Pete told me to come here,” Mootreddy claims.
When police arrived, Mootreddy told them she had a ‘telepathic love affair’ with the 27-year-old entertainer, police said.
At one point during the bizarre interaction, Mootreddy allegedly told Davidson’s mother that she was responsible for the packages and letters he had received since Oct. 31 at the home in Holdridge Avenue.
Agostino’s relationship with Davidson was not immediately clear. She also received an order against the suspect.
If convicted of the highest charge, he faces up to 15 years in prison.